Fatfish Menu

Welcome to Fatfish, the quintessential waterfront dining experience located at 28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY. Here, the focus is on fresh seafood and exquisitely crafted dishes, all while you enjoy stunning views of the Great South Bay.

Start your culinary journey with delightful appetizers like Wild Mushroom Rice Balls or the crowd-favorite Shrimp in Trench Coats. The menu balances flavors with options like the Pork Chop adorned in sweet cherry pepper sauce and Cedar River Farms Filet Mignon paired with decadent potatoes au gratin.

For seafood lovers, there’s Bronzino, available whole or filleted, alongside a daily special designed for sharing. Each plate is not just a meal; it’s a feast for the senses—especially set against the sunset backdrop. Fatfish perfectly marries exquisite flavors with a captivating ambiance. Don’t forget to make reservations to secure your spot in this delightful eatery!